When Culture Makes You Wacky: One Woman vs. Niagara Falls

in Culture Basics

Queen of the Mist logo

Queen of the Mist

Which comes first — the culture or the person?

It’s a question I ask myself a lot.

When you’re married to someone from a culture that’s not your own, you often find yourself wondering, “Is it him or is it his culture?”

As far as life’s great mysteries go, the culture-person conundrum is right up there with the chicken-and-the-egg. Or the nature-nurture debate.

But if it’s unclear where culture leaves off and an individual’s personality steps in, one thing seems certain — sometimes culture compels us to do wacky things.

Which brings me to Annie Edson Taylor, the first women to go over Niagara Falls and survive.

Ms. Taylor’s astounding and outrageous true story is the subject of the fantastic new musical drama Queen of the Mist, starring two-time Tony nominee, Mary Testa, as Annie.

Have Barrel, Will Hurtle

In 1901, the sixty-three year-old Taylor cooked up the idea of shooting the rapids in a wooden barrel that she designed herself.

Why? For fame and fortune, of course.

At least, those are the most obvious reasons. Widowed and in debt, the eccentric Ms. Taylor had already failed at several money-making schemes before she hit on her wildest idea of all. (Hey, a girl’s gotta’ make a living somehow.)

So, yes, hunger for big bucks and public adulation were part of what pushed Ms. Taylor over the brink.

But there were more powerful forces at work too.

Culture Made Her Do It

Annie was convinced that she possessed a unique and unfulfilled potential, and she was determined to manifest it. “We are all capable of that which is impossible,” she exclaims, “You must follow your dreams!”

Sound familiar? Individualism. Self-determination. The “can-do” attitude. These cultural values were already deeply embedded in the American psyche way back in 1910 when Annie triumphed over the Falls.

Fast forward 100 years and those same values still beat deep in the heart of most Americans.

  • You have nothing to fear but fear itself.
  • Be all that you can be.
  • Just do it!
  • Yes, we can.

As personal mantras, advertising gimmicks and political slogans, they’re very potent.

But if you’re not careful, you can get swept along in the current.

Just ask Annie Taylor.

Your Turn Now

What about you? How much of your behavior is just you? And how much of it is your culture? And do you ever wish you could separate the two?

Wait! What Happened to Annie?

What? You want me to spoil the story!? Go see Queen of the Mist and find out for yourself!

  • Queen of the Mist, with words and music by five-time Tony nominee Michael John LaChiusa, under the direction of Jack Cummings III, is presented by the Transport Group through December 4.
  • To purchase tickets, visit the show’s website and use the MamaDrama discount code TGMAMA for $10 off.
  • Visit MamaDrama on BroadwayWorld for more blog posts about Queen of the Mist.
  • Thanks to MamaDrama for providing me with complimentary tickets.

FCC Disclosure: I attended this performance, with complimentary tickets provided, as a reviewer and contributor on behalf of MamaDrama. The opinions expressed here are strictly my own.

Justine Ickes January 25, 2012

Hey Daria and Jenny, thanks for stopping by. Daria, different gestures and how cultures define “personal space” is so interesting. Ditto, for dreaming big, Jenny. I’ve always wondered if we developed this “living large” trait in the U.S. because we literally have such a large geographic territory – practically a whole continent! :-)

Reply

jenny - sugar loco January 25, 2012

I had never heard that story before. Holy SMOKES! She deserves fame and fortune if she can hurdle herself (in a barrel, no less) off Niagra Falls.

I guess I’ve never thought about how my culture has put me where I am. I guess I dream big – maybe that’s me, maybe that’s the American in me?

Reply

Daria January 10, 2012

I am always amazed to see how much bolder Americans are with our body language than other cultures. We just physically take up more space somehow (and not just because of our weight), but how we hold ourselves, gesture, etc. It’s interesting for sure.
Daria recently posted..Insanity Deals WebsiteMy Profile

Reply

Justine Ickes December 24, 2011

Hi Gillian, Thanks for stopping by and glad you like my blog. Sounds like Annie Taylor and Annie Kopchovsky had a lot in common. How did you first happen on her story? I came across a review of Wheels of Change: How Women Rode the Bicycle to Freedom (With a Few Flat Tires Along the Way). Maybe some other interesting women featured in the book that you might want to check out.

Reply

Gillian December 18, 2011

Hi Justine: I came across your blog while doing some googling on Annie Taylor. You have great content here!
I was researching Ms. Taylor because I’m making a documentary about another quirky, gutsy Annie from the 19th century. Her name is Annie “Londonderry” Kopchovksy, and she rode around the world on a bicycle in 1895 as part of a dare that “no woman could do it.” Annie has been a muse for all sorts of media. It all started with a book by Peter Zheutlin, and has been followed by songs, theater performances, artwork, and of course my documentary film, “The New Woman.” Follow my film’s progress on my facebook page or at the new twitter feed, @thenewwomanfilm

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Older post:

Newer post: